Potion
Potion of Bloodlust
First appears in Book 4, Chapter 23 of The Gate of the Feral Gods.
Spoiler check. Everything below is from Book 4, Chapter 23, where Potion of Bloodlust first appears. Not there yet? Set your bookmark, and the guide shows Potion of Bloodlust only as far as you have read.
Potion of Bloodlust as of Book 4, Chapter 23

What
A pair of magical potions in Carl's possession, found in his Pacifist box; identified by Mordecai as an extremely dangerous berserking potion.
Effect
STR x2, speed x2, DEX x.5, CON x.5, plus memory-loss debuff; each kill adds +25% speed.
First seen
Carl received two Potions of Bloodlust inside his Pacifist box.
At this point
Carl has both potions, stored away unused, while considering the cookbook for safer applications.
Why it matters
Mordecai warned that drinking it once made someone accidentally kill half their own party, so Carl looked for a way to use it without drinking it.