Potion
Potion of Charm Animal
First appears in Book 5, Chapter 43 of The Butcher's Masquerade.
Spoiler check. Everything below is from Book 5, Chapter 43, where Potion of Charm Animal first appears. Not there yet? Set your bookmark, and the guide shows Potion of Charm Animal only as far as you have read.
Potion of Charm Animal as of Book 5, Chapter 43

What
A brewable potion recipe found by Carl, associated with Mordecai the alchemist; must be brewed for a specific target animal using that animal's blood as the key ingredient.
First seen
Found inside Carl's silver Apothecary box, alongside a recipe and a drawing of Mongo.
At this point
Recipe held by Carl and Mordecai; not yet brewed. Donut has refused to supply the required blood.
Why it matters
Mordecai says he has chased this recipe for fifty cycles; brewing it requires a liter of blood from a specific animal, collected outside a saferoom without killing it.