Potion
Pawna's Cries
First appears in Book 5, Chapter 55 of The Butcher's Masquerade.
Spoiler check. Everything below is from Book 5, Chapter 55, where Pawna's Cries first appears. Not there yet? Set your bookmark, and the guide shows Pawna's Cries only as far as you have read.
Pawna's Cries as of Book 5, Chapter 55

What
A potion from Carl's benefactor box that grants a +3 bonus to any spell or skill the drinker chooses, with a limited shelf life; a hidden note names it as meant for Princess Donut.
Effect
+3 to a chosen spell or skill; limited shelf life.
First seen
Appeared in Carl's benefactor box; Carl then offered it to Donut in exchange for her wearing the constitution nipple ring.
At this point
Carl holds the potion, having offered it to Donut if she wears the constitution ring; her decision is not yet reported.
Why it matters
A hidden note reveals sponsor Circe backs Diwata and that this potion should secretly go to Donut, hinting at unseen manipulation behind Carl's rewards.