Potion
Lemonade
First appears in Book 4, Chapter 16 of The Gate of the Feral Gods.
Spoiler check. Everything below is from Book 4, Chapter 16, where Lemonade first appears. Not there yet? Set your bookmark, and the guide shows Lemonade only as far as you have read.
Lemonade as of Book 4, Chapter 16

What
A yellow drink Bonnie mixes from a recipe her father gave her; examined in-game as an 'Unknown Potion' labeled Lemonade. Mordecai suspects it may matter for an incoming boss fight, but it proves to be ordinary, non-magical lemonade.
Effect
None stated beyond minor blunt damage when swung; the System AI confirms it has no magical effect.
First seen
Bonnie repeatedly pushed a shotglass of the yellow liquid on Carl and Donut inside the flying house, saying her father gave her the recipe.
At this point
Carl took the freshly stirred pitcher from Bonnie over her protests and used it to strike Denise during the boss fight.
Why it matters
Mordecai warned it might be important to the coming boss battle, so Carl secured rather than drank it; it turned out to be a deliberate misdirection—just lemonade.
Also new in Book 4, Chapter 16
- Ghazi Person