Potion
I Take it All Back
First appears in Book 5, Chapter 57 of The Butcher's Masquerade.
Spoiler check. Everything below is from Book 5, Chapter 57, where I Take it All Back first appears. Not there yet? Set your bookmark, and the guide shows I Take it All Back only as far as you have read.
I Take it All Back as of Book 5, Chapter 57

What
A black, bubbling potion tagged for Princess Donut. It removes any effects of Scolopendra's Transmutation spell. Delivered to Prepotente via his benefactor box, apparently meant for Donut, not him.
Effect
Removes effects of Scolopendra's Transmutation spell.
First seen
Prepotente pulled it from his benefactor box and set it on the table before Donut, saying he was delivering a package.
At this point
Sits on the table in front of Donut; Carl has picked it up and examined it. Not yet used.
Why it matters
A tagged benefactor-box mystery item meant only for Donut, explicitly forbidden from reaching Tina, tied to undoing a transmutation curse.