Material
Hunter hands
First appears in Book 5, Chapter 63 of The Butcher's Masquerade.
Spoiler check. Everything below is from Book 5, Chapter 63, where Hunter hands first appears. Not there yet? Set your bookmark, and the guide shows Hunter hands only as far as you have read.
Hunter hands as of Book 5, Chapter 63

What
Severed hands taken as trophies from hunters that Carl and his allies have killed, kept as proof of kills for a promised in-game reward system.
First seen
Mentioned by Carl, who says he has a whole stash of hands taken from hunters he has killed.
At this point
Carl holds a stash of hunter hands in his inventory; not yet turned in anywhere.
Why it matters
Establishes that killing hunters yields collectible trophies, tied to a rule that a prize counter will exist for turning them in.